Skip to content
STATE:
NFIB Logo
Why NFIB
Our Purpose
About NFIB Policy Agenda Victories Benefits of Membership
Take Action
Get Involved
Policies Elections Events
Key Resources
Member Ballot How Congress Voted
Get Support
Business Area
Human Resources Legal & Compliance
Key Resources
Legal Guides Workplace Posters Case Index
Stay Informed
Education
Trends & Research News Webinars Small Business Podcast
Key Resources
SBET Jobs Report Problems and Priorities Tax Survey
Podcast Podcast
Careers Careers
Login Login
Why NFIB
Our Purpose
About NFIB Policy Agenda Victories Benefits of Membership
Take Action
Get Involved
Policies Elections Events
Key Resources
Member Ballot How Congress Voted
Get Support
Business Area
Human Resources Legal & Compliance
Key Resources
Legal Guides Workplace Posters Case Index
Stay Informed
Education
Trends & Research News Webinars Small Business Podcast
Key Resources
SBET Jobs Report Problems and Priorities Tax Survey
Podcast
Careers
Login
Join Now
Home / News / Press Release /

NFIB Files Amicus Brief Challenging New Evidentiary Standard

NFIB Files Amicus Brief Challenging New Evidentiary Standard

August 20, 2024

Press Release

E.M.D. Sales, Inc. v. Carrera concerns FLSA exceptions and overtime pay requirements

WASHINGTON, D.C. (Aug. 20, 2024) – NFIB filed an amicus brief in the case E.M.D Sales, Inc. v. Faustino Sanchez Carrera at the United States Supreme Court. The case considers what standard of proof should be used to determine if an exemption to employers’ overtime pay requirements applies under the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA). NFIB filed the brief with the U.S. Chamber Litigation Center.

“The traditional standard provided a straightforward evidentiary burden for determining FLSA exceptions, but the Fourth Circuit’s excessive evidence standard places employers as a distinct disadvantage,” said Beth Milito, Executive Director of NFIB’s Small Business Legal Center. “Small employers do not have the resources of their larger counterparts and will be the least able to defend themselves. As is so often the case, small businesses will be disproportionately impacted by this imbalance. NFIB urges the Court to reverse.”

NFIB’s amicus brief argues three main points: 1) Since Congress has never specified a standard for determining burden of proof in the FLSA, exceptions should be adjudicated under the established, traditional “preponderance of the evidence” standard, 2) The “clear and convincing evidence” standard draws no support for the FLSA’s overarching objectives, encourages frivolous claims against employers, and ultimately harms consumers, 3) The Fourth Circuit’s standard will disproportionately impact small businesses, and 4) Adopting the traditional “preponderance of the evidence” standard would not unduly burden employees or prevent them from seeking or recovering overtime pay.

The NFIB Small Business Legal Center protects the rights of small business owners in the nation’s courts. NFIB is currently active in more than 40 cases in federal and state courts across the country and in the U.S. Supreme Court.

Topics:
Legal
U.S. Supreme Court

Get to know NFIB

NFIB is a member-driven organization advocating on behalf of small and independent businesses nationwide.

Learn More
Receive our newsletter and email notification
Knowledge is power. Let us help you stay informed with breaking legislative news, regulatory updates, business tips, and more.

Related Articles

July 28, 2025
NFIB Expert Urges Congress to Reform Credit Card Swipe Fees 
Andrea McGee, NFIB Principal of Federal Government Relations, published an…
Read More
July 24, 2025
AUDIO: NFIB’s Brad Close and Jeff Brabant Discuss Landmark…
NFIB President Brad Close and NFIB Vice President of Federal Government Rel…
Read More
July 24, 2025
Understanding the H-2A Temporary Agricultural Visa Program
Under the Immigration Nationality Act, the federal government manages work…
Read More
July 22, 2025
Federal Requirements Governing Agricultural Employment
If you own and operate a business in the agricultural sector, it is crucial…
Read More
Loading…
NFIB
About NFIB Benefits of Membership Membership FAQs
Advocacy Center Elections Center Legal Center Research Center
Join Now
Media
Media Resources Media Contacts
Partner with NFIB
Careers Become a Provider Candidate Resources
Helpful Links
Contact PAC Contributions Legal Contributions Schedule a Call with NFIB
Follow Us
Stay Informed with NFIB

© 2001 - 2025 National Federation of Independent Business. All Rights Reserved. Terms and Conditions | Privacy Policy | Accessibility