Skip to content

NFIB NY: Protect small businesses from outrageous frequency-of-pay lawsuits

NFIB NY: Protect small businesses from outrageous frequency-of-pay lawsuits

April 15, 2024 Last Edit: July 25, 2024

Last week, NFIB State Director Ashley Ranslow published an op-ed in the Albany Times Union on the latest scourge of predatory lawsuits targeting small businesses.

Read more about this pressing issue and NFIB’s efforts in the capital to stop these outrageous lawsuits below and on the Times Union website HERE.

Commentary: Protect small businesses from outrageous frequency-of-pay lawsuits

A proposal in the executive budget would bar exorbitant claims against small businesses whose only error was that they paid workers bi-weekly, not weekly.

By 

April 12, 2024

Walking through your neighborhood, you pass countless small businesses – barber shops, dry cleaners, bodegas, restaurants, independent retailers, mechanics – owned by hard-working people. These are businesses without dedicated human resources staff, unable to afford keeping a lawyer on retainer. That makes them easy targets for ruthless plaintiffs’ attorneys who know that small operators struggle to defend themselves.

Plaintiffs’ attorneys can bleed small businesses dry through lawsuits and quick settlements adding up to big paydays. It’s an old tactic, and now plaintiffs’ attorneys have found a new cash cow: suing small businesses that paid their workers bi-weekly instead of weekly.

A century-old statute, Labor Law §191, requires businesses to pay “manual workers” on a weekly basis, defining “manual worker” as a “mechanic, workingman or laborer.”  Historically, employees challenged frequency-of-pay requirements by filing a complaint with the state Department of Labor, which determined whether employees would be paid weekly. This changed in 2019, when the Appellate Division in Vega v. CM & Associates Construction Management, LLC, held that payment of wages to “manual workers” other than weekly empowers a private right of action allowing a worker to seek damages equal to 50 percent of their wages for six years, plus interest and attorneys’ fees.

Vega has led to hundreds of businesses, including small businesses, being sued for millions of dollars. These exorbitant amounts are being claimed even in cases where employees were paid their full wages owed. While a large number of these cases remain pending, a considerable number were settled to avoid the excessive amounts being sought in court.

Yes, many of these cases involve employees that were paid for every hour they worked. The only error was that they were paid bi-weekly, not weekly.

Moreover, a small-business owner who mistakenly pays bi-weekly (as many states and federal law permit) and categorizes employees as non-manual, could be liable for up to 50 percent of worker wages for the past six years. A family-owned hardware store with 10 longtime employees making $25 per hour could be on the hook for over $1.5 million in damages.

Most small businesses would be ruined by this. Assessing such damages where employees were paid full wages is unequivocally wrong.

Fortunately, there is a solution to protect Main Street businesses from these absurd lawsuits. Gov. Kathy Hochul’s executive budget proposal includes a provision to clarify that small businesses and other employers are not subject to these extreme damages if they were paid at least semi-monthly. This is a practical and reasonable solution that will dissuade plaintiffs’ attorneys from gouging small businesses where there was no harm to the employee.

The governor’s proposal is true to the existing statute, which historically did not award egregious amounts for workers who had been paid. It’s also supported by a recent appellate court decision, Grant v. Global Aircraft Dispatch, which sensibly found that frequency of payment claims shouldn’t be treated the same as nonpayment and underpayment of wages.

These multi-million-dollar lawsuits must end. Otherwise more small businesses will be shuttered and more jobs will be lost. It’s imperative that the Senate and Assembly include the governor’s common-sense proposal in the final budget deal.

Ashley Ranslow is the New York state director of the National Federation of Independent Business.

Get to know NFIB

NFIB is a member-driven organization advocating on behalf of small and independent businesses nationwide.

Receive our newsletter and email notification
Knowledge is power. Let us help you stay informed with breaking legislative news, regulatory updates, business tips, and more.

Related Articles

December 11, 2024
TAKE ACTION: Help the Voice of Small Business Be Heard By Votin…
Your input helps determine our positions on key issues affecting independen…
Read More
December 11, 2024
REMINDER: Upcoming Changes to the Commercial Activity Tax
Read More
December 11, 2024
West Virginia Small Businesses Optimism Jumps to Three-Year Hig…
#post_content Main Street breaks 34-month streak of record high uncertainty
Read More
December 10, 2024
New York City Named 2nd Worst “Judicial Hellhole” in Countr…
The American Tort Reform Foundation’s annual “Judicial Hellholes” rep…
Read More

© 2001 - 2024 National Federation of Independent Business. All Rights Reserved. Terms and Conditions | Privacy Policy | Accessibility