Skip to content
STATE:
NFIB Logo
Why NFIB
Our Purpose
About NFIB Policy Agenda Victories Benefits of Membership
Take Action
Get Involved
Policies Elections Events
Key Resources
Member Ballot How Congress Voted
Get Support
Business Area
Human Resources Legal & Compliance
Key Resources
Legal Guides Workplace Posters Case Index
Stay Informed
Education
Trends & Research News Webinars Small Business Podcast
Key Resources
SBET Jobs Report Problems and Priorities Tax Survey
Podcast Podcast
Careers Careers
Login Login
Why NFIB
Our Purpose
About NFIB Policy Agenda Victories Benefits of Membership
Take Action
Get Involved
Policies Elections Events
Key Resources
Member Ballot How Congress Voted
Get Support
Business Area
Human Resources Legal & Compliance
Key Resources
Legal Guides Workplace Posters Case Index
Stay Informed
Education
Trends & Research News Webinars Small Business Podcast
Key Resources
SBET Jobs Report Problems and Priorities Tax Survey
Podcast
Careers
Login
Join Now
Home / News / Analysis /

Small Businesses Get Key Wins During 2024-25 U.S. Supreme Court Term

Small Businesses Get Key Wins During 2024-25 U.S. Supreme Court Term

July 10, 2025

NFIB secured three wins during the U.S. Supreme Court’s 2024-25 term

Through a relatively quiet U.S. Supreme Court 2024-25 term, the NFIB Small Business Legal Center secured three much-needed wins for small businesses. Of the seven total cases the Legal Center participated in, NFIB had three wins, three losses, and one neutral decision. The Legal Center’s participation in seven cases represents over 10% of the Supreme Court’s cases for the term.  

Though there were some disappointing results, a few key wins will continue to propel the interests of small businesses. 

  • City & County of San Francisco v. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA): 

This case dealt with the EPA imposing certain prohibitions on pollutant discharge permits that focused on the “end-result” water instead of specific discharges by a regulated entity. The Supreme Court agreed with NFIB’s brief, concluding that the Clean Water Act did not authorize generic “end-result” water permitting conditions.     

  • E.M.D. Sales, Inc. v. Carrera: 

This case covered minimum wage and overtime pay provisions of the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA), which includes certain exemptions from overtime pay requirements. NFIB argued that the proper showing that an employee is exempt is the preponderance-of-the-evidence standard. The Supreme Court unanimously agreed.  

  • Diamond Alternative Energy v. EPA: 

This case involved companies who were indirectly affected by regulations placed by administrative agencies and their ability to challenge those regulations in court. NFIB argued they should be able to challenge those regulations, and the Supreme Court agreed.

  • Laboratory Corporation of America Holdings v. Davis:

This case dealt with class action lawsuits, where businesses needed the court to make clear that class action lawsuits cannot include uninjured individuals. NFIB’s amicus brief argued that including uninjured individuals violates constitutional requirements and federal rules. The Supreme Court sidestepped this issue, dismissing the case.

  • Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. Zuch: 

This case revolved around the jurisdiction of the United States Tax Court and accountability regarding the IRS. NFIB’s brief argued that the IRS should not be allowed to resort to “self-help” during a taxpayer’s pre-tax levy challenge and then claim that the same “self-help” disposed of the taxpayer’s legal challenge. The Supreme Court disagreed. 

  • Federal Communications Commission (FCC) v. Consumers’ Research: 

This case asked whether Congress could delegate legislative authority to the FCC, and the FCC delegate that authority to a private entity, the Universal Service Administrative Company (USAC). NFIB filed an amicus brief arguing that this action was unconstitutional because it gave too much authority to an unaccountable private entity. The court disagreed.  

  • Trump v. CASA, Inc: 

This case considered whether federal district courts can block the government from enforcing a law or policy anywhere in the country, against any person, if the district court determines that the law or policy is likely unconstitutional. NFIB’s business coalition amicus brief argued that district courts have that authority, but the Supreme Court ruled that district courts do not have that general authority. This means the government can institute questionable laws or policies against small businesses until the business either sues the government directly or joins a class action lawsuit.   

The NFIB Small Business Legal Center will continue to fight for the rights of small businesses when the 2025-26 Supreme Court term begins this fall. Contact the NFIB Small Business Legal Center at info@nfib.org with any questions.

Topics:
Legal
Regulations
U.S. Supreme Court

Get to know NFIB

NFIB is a member-driven organization advocating on behalf of small and independent businesses nationwide.

Learn More
Receive our newsletter and email notification
Knowledge is power. Let us help you stay informed with breaking legislative news, regulatory updates, business tips, and more.

Related Articles

July 10, 2025
Historic Legislation Becomes Law and Stops Massive Tax Hike on…
The One Big Beautiful Bill Act is signed into law, permanently extending th…
Read More
July 10, 2025
LISTEN: NFIB’s Josh McLeod Discusses Beneficial Ownership Rep…
NFIB is urging Congress to repeal the Beneficial Ownership Information (BOI…
Read More
July 9, 2025
Small Businesses Succeed in Challenge to FTC’s Automatic Rene…
NFIB wins lawsuit challenging the FTC’s Negative Option Rule, which targe…
Read More
U.S. Capitol Building
July 8, 2025
AUDIO: NFIB’s Jeff Brabant Discusses BOI Repeal on SiriusXM…
NFIB Vice President of Federal Government Relations Jeff Brabant joined POT…
Read More
Loading…
NFIB
About NFIB Benefits of Membership Membership FAQs
Advocacy Center Elections Center Legal Center Research Center
Join Now
Media
Media Resources Media Contacts
Partner with NFIB
Careers Become a Provider Candidate Resources
Helpful Links
Contact PAC Contributions Legal Contributions Schedule a Call with NFIB
Follow Us
Stay Informed with NFIB

© 2001 - 2025 National Federation of Independent Business. All Rights Reserved. Terms and Conditions | Privacy Policy | Accessibility